Renters Insurance

Best Renters Insurance Companies for Apartments and Rentals

Renters insurance protects your belongings and provides liability coverage for surprisingly little cost. These top-rated renters insurance companies offer comprehensive coverage starting under $15 per month.

Pick your favorites · Every vote moves the ranking · Results update live
← Lists
12 items
Your votes move these rankings⚡ Battle mode
Sort
01
A

Actual Cash Value vs Replacement Cost Coverage

Actual cash value pays depreciated value of stolen items (so a 5-year-old $1,000 laptop might pay $200). Replacement cost pays what it costs to buy the same item new today — always worth the small premium increase.

Steady·Score +20
02
N

Nationwide Renters Insurance

Competitive pricing with valuable add-ons including credit card fraud protection and watercraft coverage. Their SmartRide telematics auto bundle offers significant combined savings.

Steady·Score +16
03
H

How Much Renters Insurance Do You Need?

Take a home inventory listing all belongings with estimated values — most people discover they own $20,000–$50,000 in personal property. Choose coverage limits that match your inventory, not the cheapest option.

Steady·Score +9
04
A

American Family Renters Insurance

Strong coverage with a loyalty rewards program and generous bundling discounts. Available in 19 states with competitive claims satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power.

Steady·Score +8
05
S

State Farm Renters Insurance

Reliable, comprehensive renters coverage from America's largest insurer with exceptional local agent support. Bundle with State Farm auto for meaningful discounts on both policies.

Steady·Score +8
06
H

Hippo Renters Insurance

Includes smart home monitoring devices with policies and covers electronics like laptops and gaming systems more comprehensively than traditional renters policies. Excellent for tech-heavy renters.

Steady·Score +7
07
U

USAA Renters Insurance

The best renters insurance for military members and families — includes identity theft protection, flood coverage, and earthquake coverage as standard features not found in civilian policies.

Steady·Score +6
08
L

Lemonade Renters Insurance

Starting at $5/month, Lemonade's app-based renters insurance pays claims in seconds via AI. Flat-fee structure and charitable giveback make it the most popular choice among young renters.

Steady·Score +5
09
D

Does Renters Insurance Cover Roommates?

Standard policies only cover the named insured — roommates need their own policies. Some insurers allow adding a domestic partner; unmarried roommates are generally not covered under someone else's policy.

Steady·Score +5
10
A

Allstate Renters Insurance

Clear, straightforward coverage with a helpful digital claims experience. Allstate's HostAdvantage add-on covers belongings when renting your home on Airbnb — unique to their renters policies.

Steady·Score +3
11
T

Toggle Renters Insurance

A Farmers subsidiary offering fully customizable renters policies — choose exactly what you need to cover: electronics, jewelry, bicycles, or sports equipment in a modular subscription model.

Steady·Score +2
12
W

What Renters Insurance Actually Covers

Personal property (theft, fire, water damage), personal liability if someone is injured in your apartment, and additional living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable. Does NOT cover the building itself.

Steady·Score -1
Predict the rank

Actual Cash Value vs Replacement Cost Coverage

Currently ranked #1. Where will it be in 7 days?